Pharmachronicles

Top Menu

  • Home
  • Our Blog
  • Contact Us

Main Menu

  • Home Page
  • STUDENTS ZONE
  • Syllabus
  • Seminars & conferences
  • Online classes
    • Register
Sign in / Join

Login

Welcome! Login in to your account
Lost your password?

Lost Password

Back to login
  • Home
  • Our Blog
  • Contact Us

logo

  • Home Page
  • STUDENTS ZONE
  • Syllabus
  • Seminars & conferences
  • Online classes
    • Register
  • Overcoming Vaccine Hesitancy: How Pharmacists Build Patient Confidence

  • Resurgence of COVID-19 in Hong Kong and Singapore: A New Wave Driven by Waning Immunity and Emerging Variants

  • How Pharmacists Support Chronic Disease Management in the Community

  • OTC Medications: Safe Use, Common Mistakes, and Pharmacist Guidance

  • Pharmacovigilance Explained: Why Reporting Adverse Drug Reactions Saves Lives

Uncategorized
Home›Uncategorized›UGC Scraps CARE Journals List: A Bold Reform or a Risky Move?

UGC Scraps CARE Journals List: A Bold Reform or a Risky Move?

By Pharmachronicles
February 25, 2025
1526
0
Share:

Dr.N.Sriram,

Founder & CEO, Genesis Research Labs, S.R.Nagar, Hyderabad.

Introduction

The University Grants Commission (UGC) has made a controversial decision to discontinue the UGC Consortium for Academic and Research Ethics (UGC-CARE) list, a quality control mechanism introduced in 2018 to standardize academic publishing. This move has received mixed reactions from the academic community, with many questioning its impact on research quality, transparency, and integrity.

While UGC defends the decision as a step towards decentralization and academic freedom, several academicians argue that it opens the door to misuse and a decline in research standards.

So, is this a necessary reform or a risky decision that could harm the academic ecosystem? Let’s explore the debate in detail.

Why Was the UGC-CARE List Introduced?

The UGC-CARE list was introduced in 2018 to combat the rise of predatory journals and ensure that faculty and students publish their research in reliable, peer-reviewed journals. It served several key functions:
✔️ Quality Assurance: Identified trusted academic journals.
✔️ Promotion & Evaluation: Ensured faculty promotions were based on credible research.
✔️ Institutional Ranking: Helped determine institutional credibility based on publications.
✔️ Research Grants & Recognition: Provided a standardized benchmark for funding agencies.

However, the UGC has now replaced this system with suggestive parameters, allowing Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) to develop their own mechanisms for evaluating journal quality.

The Decision to Scrap UGC-CARE: The Justification

According to UGC Chairman Mamidala Jagadesh Kumar, the UGC-CARE list was abolished due to concerns over:

  • Excessive Centralization: The top-down approach limited institutional flexibility.
  • Lack of Transparency: Unclear processes for adding and removing journals.
  • Assessment Inefficiencies: The list did not always guarantee quality research.

The new policy suggests “parameters for peer-reviewed journals”, focusing on criteria like:
📌 Editorial Transparency – Clear information about the editorial board.
📌 Journal Visibility – Wider recognition in academic circles.
📌 Peer-Review Policy – A rigorous review process.
📌 Research Ethics – Adherence to ethical publishing standards.

“This decentralized approach allows HEIs to tailor their evaluation processes to suit their specific needs,” said Kumar. “Researchers will no longer be constrained by a centralized list of journals, allowing for greater academic freedom.”

Backlash from the Academic Community

While UGC argues that decentralization will enhance academic flexibility, several academicians disagree, calling the decision a step backward.

🔴 Fear of Research Quality Decline

B Manohar, professor at Osmania University, emphasized:
“The UGC-CARE list was introduced to curb the practice of publishing in predatory journals. Now, without a mandatory list, faculty and students may publish in subpar journals just to meet requirements.”

Rajesh Gacche, HOD of Biotechnology at SPPU, echoed similar concerns:
“Most universities in India lack the infrastructure for high-quality research. Now, they will assemble their own list of journals that suit them. This will compromise research quality.”

🔴 Risk of Manipulation and Unethical Practices

Sunita Salunkhe, professor at SPPU’s Department of Chemistry, warned:
“If universities are allowed to create their own journal lists, I can start my own journal and publish in it. This right should not be given to universities; it should be a national standard.”

She also argued that SCOPUS-based journals should be made compulsory for research credibility.

🔴 Confusion Among Researchers

Ankit Rawal, HOD of the Sanskrit Department at Fergusson College, stated:
“Without a central list, researchers will struggle to identify reliable journals. This could lead to misuse and manipulation.”

Similarly, Mahesh Dawange, assistant professor at SPPU’s Hindi Department, added:
“A lack of regulation will create inconsistencies—some journals will be considered credible in one city but not in another. This will create unnecessary academic disputes.”

Some Support the Decision

Not everyone is against the removal of UGC-CARE. Some academicians argue that the list was flawed and lacked transparency.

D Ravinder, former Vice-Chancellor of Osmania University, pointed out:
“Journals were often added or removed from the CARE list based on professor recommendations, without a clear process. A peer-review-based system, as used worldwide, is a better approach.”

Additionally, Md Shakir Shaikh, HOD of Hindi at Poona College, argued:
“Even before ISSN and ISBN numbers existed, research was published and read. Good research speaks for itself, regardless of where it is published. The CARE list also had long waiting times, making publishing difficult.”

Potential Consequences of the Decision

✅ Possible Benefits:

✔️ More flexibility in journal selection.
✔️ Encouragement of independent evaluation instead of a predefined list.
✔️ Academic freedom to publish in diverse journals.

❌ Possible Risks:

❌ Increase in predatory publishing, making it easier for low-quality research to be recognized.
❌ Lack of standardization, leading to academic disparities across universities.
❌ Risk of favoritism, as universities might approve their own journals for faculty promotions.

Final Verdict: A Step Forward or Backward?

The decision to scrap the UGC-CARE list is a double-edged sword.
🟢 If HEIs develop robust evaluation mechanisms, this could improve research quality and academic freedom.
🔴 However, if quality control is weak, this move could lead to a rise in substandard and predatory publishing.

At a time when India is positioning itself as a global research hub, this decision could either democratize publishing or lower research credibility.

What’s Your Opinion?

💬 Should the UGC-CARE list have been removed?
💬 Will this decision improve research freedom or harm academic standards?
Drop your thoughts in the comments below! 🚀📚

Prof. N. Sriram, M.Pharm., PhD

Editor,

Pharmachroncles.

Hyderabad

pharmachronicles@gmail.com

+91 9704361947

Previous Article

Simplified Guide to the PhD Process in ...

Next Article

Impact of Proposed U.S. Trade Tariffs on ...

0
Shares
  • 0
  • +
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0
  • 0

Pharmachronicles

Related articles More from author

  • Uncategorized

    Top 10 Trends Shaping the Future of Pharmacy in 2024

    December 18, 2024
    By admin
  • Uncategorized

    Jobs

    August 30, 2017
    By admin
  • Uncategorized

    Hypertension May Increase Heart Failure Risk after child birth in women’s

    February 15, 2020
    By Pharmachronicles
  • PublicationsUncategorized

    List of UGC Approved journals 2020

    October 20, 2020
    By admin
  • Uncategorized

    Telangana Pharmacist Grade-II model paper

    April 12, 2018
    By ayyappa reddy
  • Uncategorized

    National level exams for Ph.D entrance.

    October 23, 2017
    By admin

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You may interested

  • Notifications

    Pursuing MPhil/PhD while working as a teacher will effect experience: UGC

  • Uncategorized

    Blood Test Might Predict Pregnancy Due Date and Preterm Birth

  • Medical & Health

    A trial finds new revolution in migraine treatment

  • LATEST REVIEWS

  • TOP REVIEWS

  • Pharmacists are not eligible for certificate program of community health

    0
  • A New Class of Antimicrobials Has Just Been Found in Human Breast Milk Fresh super ...

    0

Timeline

  • May 20, 2025

    Overcoming Vaccine Hesitancy: How Pharmacists Build Patient Confidence

  • May 17, 2025

    Resurgence of COVID-19 in Hong Kong and Singapore: A New Wave Driven by Waning Immunity and Emerging Variants

  • May 9, 2025

    How Pharmacists Support Chronic Disease Management in the Community

  • May 9, 2025

    OTC Medications: Safe Use, Common Mistakes, and Pharmacist Guidance

  • May 7, 2025

    Pharmacovigilance Explained: Why Reporting Adverse Drug Reactions Saves Lives

Latest Comments

  • Pharmachronicles
    on
    February 27, 2025
    Thank you sir

    Streamlining Salaries through Payment Credit System and Other Benefits for Pharmacy Professionals: Suggestive Measures for PCI ...

  • G Krishna moorthy
    on
    February 1, 2025
    Good 👍 efforts Congratulations Continue your valuable professional services

    Streamlining Salaries through Payment Credit System and Other Benefits for Pharmacy Professionals: Suggestive Measures for PCI ...

  • Aarati sonawane
    on
    January 31, 2025
    Use in toppical application

    Role of Artificial Intelligence in 3D Printing Personalized Medication

  • Sowmya V
    on
    December 13, 2019
    Nice keep it up

    Blood Test Might Predict Pregnancy Due Date and Preterm Birth

Find us on Facebook

Follow Us on Instagram

logo

Dui viverra Faucibus aliquet quis phasellus accumsan. Donec et facilisis sociosqu sed tortor elit eu aliquid turpis ridiculus.

Fly, shall, have greater fifth spirit midst under from stars thing is, had creepeth multiply kind. Man may they’re meat years have third bring replenish air two light deep fill.

About us

  • Dr.N.Sriram, Founder CEO, Pharmachronicles, HITS college of Pharmacy, Ghatkesar, Hyderabad, India
  • 9704361947
  • pharmachronicles@gmail.com
  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • Overcoming Vaccine Hesitancy: How Pharmacists Build Patient Confidence

    By Pharmachronicles
    May 20, 2025
  • Resurgence of COVID-19 in Hong Kong and Singapore: A New Wave Driven by Waning Immunity ...

    By Pharmachronicles
    May 17, 2025
  • How Pharmacists Support Chronic Disease Management in the Community

    By Pharmachronicles
    May 9, 2025
  • OTC Medications: Safe Use, Common Mistakes, and Pharmacist Guidance

    By Pharmachronicles
    May 9, 2025
  • pharmacy credit system

    Streamlining Salaries through Payment Credit System and Other Benefits for Pharmacy Professionals: Suggestive Measures for ...

    By Pharmachronicles
    February 1, 2025
  • Blood Test Might Predict Pregnancy Due Date and Preterm Birth

    By Sundari srinidhi
    December 12, 2019
  • Ai in 3D printing

    Role of Artificial Intelligence in 3D Printing Personalized Medication

    By Pharmachronicles
    January 29, 2025
  • FDA is carefully evaluating prescription opioid medications approved to treat cough in children

    By admin
    July 16, 2015
  • Pharmachronicles
    on
    February 27, 2025

    Streamlining Salaries through Payment Credit System and Other Benefits for Pharmacy Professionals: Suggestive Measures for PCI ...

    Thank you sir
  • G Krishna moorthy
    on
    February 1, 2025

    Streamlining Salaries through Payment Credit System and Other Benefits for Pharmacy Professionals: Suggestive Measures for PCI ...

    Good 👍 efforts Congratulations ...
  • Aarati sonawane
    on
    January 31, 2025

    Role of Artificial Intelligence in 3D Printing Personalized Medication

    Use in toppical application
  • Sowmya V
    on
    December 13, 2019

    Blood Test Might Predict Pregnancy Due Date and Preterm Birth

    Nice keep it up

Photostream

    Follow us

    • Contact
    • STUDENTS ZONE
    • About Us
    © Copyright Pharmachronicles. All rights reserved.